Phasing out of copper wiring in telecom networks misrepresented in some reports

Lawmakers and regulators nationwide have been looking into the move by Verizon and other incumbent phone carriers to phase out decades-old copper wiring from their networks. Along with this regulatory and legislative oversight, there have been unfounded reports that the carriers, including PTA members that service Pennsylvania’s rural areas (the RLECs), are leaving their customers high and dry without their old copper wiring. That’s simply not the case.

There are cost, technology and real marketplace reasons for getting rid of copper lines and replacing them with fiber optic cable. And all are a benefit to customers increasingly demanding higher broadband speeds at affordable pricing.

Besides bandwidth limitations, copper networks are costly to repair, and because of the high prices of the metal the lines are subject to theft for sale on the black market. Fiber has no such broadband limitations, and that’s why it’s the go-to for broadband expansion nationwide – especially where hard wiring hard is needed in many of Pennsylvania’s rural areas where satellite and other services have limitations due to terrain.

This not only enhances service by giving the RLECs the means to keep their customers up to date with the latest technology, but it also gives the carriers a chance to compete with voice and internet providers who face nothing near the regulatory hurdles they do.

In fact, the RLECs remain the only carriers of last resort (COLR), a throwback designation by state and federal regulators when the carriers had a monopoly over voice service. It was a trade-off and it made sense. Because of limitations in technology (near total reliance on copper wiring), the carriers captured all the business in their coverage areas but for that they had to guarantee service to everyone.

Technological advances have changed the market dramatically. We are now far below 10 percent of voice service in our coverage areas and yet we are still under full COLR requirements, along with other regulations that stem from technology in the distant past.

Legislation introduced in the Senate by Sen. Kristin Phillips-Hill (R-York), would have eased some of that unneeded regulatory pressure while keeping core protections for consumers. An updated Senate Bill 491 will hopefully gain full passage in the General Assembly next session.

For instance, COLR requirements would remain in those areas of the state where competition is non-existent. What’s more, the legislation maintains Section 1501 of the Pennsylvania Public Utility Code that requires public utilities to furnish and maintain adequate, efficient, safe, and reasonable service. Other protections remain as well.

There is precedence for lawmakers to address outdated and overly burdensome regulations limiting the RLECS. Back in 2004 the General Assembly, working with all interested parties including consumer groups, approved Act 183 which dialed back some regulations in return for a guarantee from PTA members that they would phase in broadband access for all customers. PTA members met all their broadband requirements. SB 491 would take the carriers even closer to a level field in a very competitive market yet still offer consumer protections.